PinotFile: 6.44 October 29, 2007
- Harvest ‘07 from the Front Lines
- Finger Lakes Has Its Own Challenges
- Bonacorssi Wine Company
- To Drink or Not to Drink?
- Red Car Wine Co: Life is a Journey
- Making Sense of Alcohol
- Acker Merrill & Condit Auction
Harvest ‘07 from the Front Lines
Rain at harvest is always the bane of winegrowers. Continued moisture can lead to
widespread grape rot along with swelling and cracked berries, not to mention
muddy vineyards making grape picking a challenge. 2007 will be remembered
both in Oregon and California as an uneventful, if not cool growing year, and quite
promising until late September and early October rains intervened. Glenn
McGourty of the UC Cooperative Extension summarized the vintage best when he
, “This is going to go down as a good vintage with a
Oregon had a variable harvest with some areas forced to bring in the crop before
the grapes were ripe. The vintage is being referred to as a “winemaker vintage,”
as the skills of vintners will be challenged to deal in some cases with grapes with
low to moderate sugars and tannins.
In California, harvest started early in most regions and crop yields for Pinot Noir
were reportedly down 20-50% compared to the generous harvest of 2006. Generally,
cluster weights were light but quality was very good.
I asked a number of winemakers and winegrowers throughout California and in
the Willamette Valley of Oregon to comment on their harvest. Overall, they were bursting with optimism. God bless ’em, winegrowers always look for the positive.
Oregon: Willamette Valley
Sheila Nicholas doubles as owner of Anam Cara Cellars and Nicholas Communications in Newberg,
Oregon. She has spoken to a number of northern Willamette Valley winemakers and vineyard managers.
She hasn’t heard any “gloom and doom” stories. There was plenty of rain, but cool temperatures
and gusty winds kept bunch rot at bay. The ground was also fairly dry, so it absorbed the rain water
and logistically most were able to harvest when they wanted, rain or no rain. Most vineyards with options
picked in stages, first by vine age/yield, clone and then by elevation. Overall, everyone kept the
fruit hanging as long as possible as flavors progressed dramatically from week to week. At Anam
Cara’s vineyard on the Chehalem Mountains, reserve rows (yield 1.5 tons/acre) were picked on the
eve of the first rains. Young vineyards in the Willamette Valley also came in early. Older vine Pommard
and Wädenswil held up well and were generally picked towards the end of the season. Thinnerskinned
Dijon clones came in earlier or mid-season. Lower lying vineyards were harvested first and
higher elevations, such as White Rose Vineyard at the top of the Dundee Hills at 850 feet and with older
vines, were not even picked until October 20-21. Vineyards such as Black Family Estate (The Four
Graces) which enjoy a progressive elevation from 300 to 600 feet, was picked in several stages, starting
at the bottom of the hill and working upwards. There was no rush and no panic. Sheila pointed out
that even though the summer was cool, the valley still had the 4th highest total of heat degree units on
record. “This was one of those harvests that we live for up here!. It was an opportunity to put skill, experience
and faith to the test. The consensus is that experience and teamwork between vineyard management
and winemaking will pay huge dividends.”
Patrick Mahaney, Director of Vineyard Marketing for Premier Pacific Vineyards, told me that the
Willamette Valley had “a fantastic growing season, although the winter and spring rainfall was closer
to normal.” The days were beautiful and sunny with very little precipitation during the growing season.
A significant amount of fruit was harvested from the Gran Moraine Vineyard in the Yamhill-
Carlton District before the October rains hit. The Roserock, Zena Crown and Willakia sites in the Eola-
Amity Hills AVA were not quite mature when the rains hit, so harvesting took place during breaks in
the storms. Fortunately, there were enough breaks so the vines continued maturing their fruit and “we
were able to harvest ripe, dry Pinot Noir that should deliver some great wines.” Importantly, botrytis
was not an issue. This was most likely due to a combination of good farming practices and the fact that
the storms originated in the Gulf of Alaska and therefore brought cooler temperatures along with the
Joe Wright, winemaker at Belle Vallee Cellars located in
the more southern portion of the Willamette Valley in
Corvallis was very pleased with this year’s harvest. The
last fruit came in on October 26. 60% of their best Pinot
Noir for barrel aging came in from Stermer, Freedom Hill,
Momtazi, Left Coast and Alpine vineyards by Friday, September
28th, beautifully ripe. The rain started that night
and continued pretty much nonstop through the end of October.
“Overall, I think this is a classic case of growing
conditions on the edge of viticulture success. What was
brought in before the rains already shows a wide range of
blue and black fruit with great acid and a large proportion
of malic acid should turn into plush velvet. Picks within
short windows of fair weather show a broad range of red and blue fruit, more delicate and elegant,
but complex and intense.”
Larry Londer of Londer Vineyards reported that harvest ended mid October in the Anderson Valley.
The summer started out cool, then got into the mid 90s during mid-September. Many people picked
by the 3rd week of September. It then turned cold and rained a few times which precipitated another
round of picking. The weather became nice again during the first week of October and most picked
during this week. “My last pick was on October 9th and it started raining that afternoon (heavy) which
lasted for nine straight days.” In general, yields for Pinot Noir in Mendocino County were down 15-
20% from last year. Lucky for him, he predicted a light year and left an extra bud when he pruned.
His yields were almost the same as last year as a result.
Russian River Valley
Pinot Noir harvest started the last week of August in warmer areas. The crop was light with yields of
Pinot Noir down by 20-50%. Kent Humphrey of Eric Kent Wine Cellars said that 2007 seemed more
like three or four harvests in one. The harvest season
started out hot, much like 2004, then cooled off slowing
the vine growth. Conditions remained cooler for a couple
of weeks before warming up to moderate temperatures.
Then the heat returned, followed by on and off
rain for two weeks. At the end of it all, some Pinot Noir
will be more like the 2004 vintage (bigger and incredibly
fruit-driven), some more like the 2006 vintage (a
touch more restraint and elegance, though not as much
as a very cool vintage like 2005) and the latest vineyards
harvested in the first week of October may offer the best
of both. “I believe the 2007 vintage will produce some of
our best wines yet.”
David Dain of Dain Wines reported that most of the harvest and crush was completed by October 14.
“It is a year of small clusters, with small berries with high skin to juice ratio. The wines, which are just
beginning MLF, appear to be dark and concentrated with good ripe flavors, healthy acidity, and reasonable
As usual, harvest was not without challenges in this cool growing region of California. Barbara Drady
of Sonoma Coast Vineyards notes that “quality is outstanding, but quantities are off substantially - some
vineyards as much as 40%. Cluster count was fine but cluster size/weight was way off.” The only vineyard
Barbara harvested that brought in more than expected was Balistreri which came in at just under
a ton per acre. “The clusters are teeny - about 3 inches long!” As of October 23, she still had about 12
tons of Chardonnay on the vines. It was only 21 Brix before the rains hit. Some botrytis will occur for
sure, but with the low sugars, it could make for a very special wine.
Don Baumhefner, winemaker for Ridgeway Vineyards in Petaluma, reported a great harvest for several
reasons. First, the famed Petaluma Gap prolonged the season and picking didn’t start until October.
Compared to the Russian River Valley, they had a full month of extra time for the grapes to gather
flavor, 30% more hang time than they expected. The grapes were in great condition and harvest was
finished on October 6. The Pommard clone has more flavor than he personally has experienced anywhere.
“Dan Berwick at Paradise Ridge, where we are crushing this year, went totally gaga over the
Pommard lot and said we should bottle it separately since it was soooooo good.”
Jeff Stewart, winemaker at Buena Vista Carneros said he was very happy with the 2007 harvest. They
started picking the younger blocks from the Ramal Vineyard on September 3 and finished the last
blocks on October 1. The first week of September was warm helping to develop good fruit intensity,
followed by slightly cooler than normal weather through the next two weeks which slowed things
down, allowing tannins to develop nicely without high sugar accumulation. The Pinot Noir shows
really nice flavors, fruit intensity and balance. “It should be a vintage that across the board gives us
wines with great power and elegance.”
The comments from Jerome Cherry, winemaker at Saintsbury, were similar. “The nice growing season
has allowed us to make very nice wines with great balance, color and concentration. I am very excited
about the wine profile overall. I believe 2007 will be a great vintage.”
Jonathan Pey of Scenic Root Winegrowers (Pey-Marin, Mt. Tamalpais, Textbook & Spicerack Vineyards)
reported very small yields. Pinot Noir was brought in from the Pey-Marin block of Corda Vineyard
on October 3, but the yield was less than ½ ton per acre. This was partially due to poor fruit set.
Some bird damage occurred for the first time in eight years so he will be netting his block next year.
Quality looks very good. He also obtained some Pinot Noir from Stewart Johnson’s Kendric Vineyard
in mid-September which is very, very good. Across Marin, the rains were a non-issue and everything
was picked before they showed up.
Mark Pasternak, who farms his own Devil’s Gulch Vineyard and manages many other vineyards in
Marin County reported that “as always, outrageous quality, lousy quantity.” The joys of farming
grapes on the edge. Dan Goldfield, winemaker at Dutton-Goldfield, who produces a Devil’s Gulch
Vineyard Pinot Noir, says the 2007 Marin County fruit may be the best he has ever seen. Mark said,
“As Dan was fondling the grapes upon delivery, he had a look on his face that can only be described in
terms not acceptable around children.”
Gideon Bienstock, proprietor and winemaker of Clos Saron, said “it was a growing season from hell.”
It started out with the earliest bud break ever, followed by nearly three weeks of nightly frosts in April,
continued with two severe hail storms in May, and ended with high humidity in August.” The result
was mildew in some locations. He lost over a third of his crop, including 100% of the Texas Hill Road
Vineyard he farms nearby and 50% of his Home Vineyard Pinot Noir. On top of the quantity losses, the
quality was uneven. He does not know how others fared in the region, but frosts were widespread in
Santa Lucia Highlands
Quantities were down by 50% compared to the last three to four years. Quality, however was terrific.
Dan Lee of Morgan Winery and the Double L Vineyard reported in winesandvines.com that “Pinot Noir
seeds are the darkest brown I’ve ever seen. I’m excited about quality, but I am crying about quantity.”
Santa Cruz Mountains
Jim Schultze reported in from Windy Oaks Winery and Vineyards in Corralitos. He pointed out that the
harvest in 2007 demonstrates why it is difficult to think of the Santa Cruz Mountains as a single
appellation. The Pinot Noir picked at vineyards at the summit and on the northeast side of the Santa
Cruz Mountains was picked very early. Crop levels were below normal much like other regions of
California. Picking began in late August or early September depending on location. Coastal Santa
Cruz Mountains is a very different story. Pinot Noir harvests in Corralitos, for example, finished in mid
October, except for Windy Oaks Estate. Jim said his harvest was just getting going on October 23 and
should be completed by the end of October. The wines will not be in barrel until Thanksgiving! The
fruit from Windy Oaks Vineyard has never looked better. Fruit set was unusually even and the clusters
looked beautfiul. Despite two inches of rain early in October, he did not detect any botrytis or mold.
“The seeds and stems are ripe and the numbers are as close as they get!”
Santa Maria Valley
Chris Hammell, Vineyard Manager at Bien Nacido Vineyards, complained, like most growers, about
the weather. A cold, dry winter and was followed by a cool, windy spring. This caused vine stunting,
low vigor and erratic fruit set. The summer, however, was beautiful. Mild nights, consistent low-tomid
seventies daytime highs and gentle afternoon breezes were the norm. Heading into veraison, the
vines were healthy and well-balanced. Harvest began the second week of September and the vintage
could turn out to be outstanding.
Ste. Rita Hills
Deborah Hall of Gypsy Canyon Winery reported that 2007 was a light harvest for everyone. No one
had any Pinot Noir for sale. The fruit is stellar, however, a smaller than expected crop with intensely
flavored berries, really beautiful fruit. Deborah’s Mission grapes were still on the vine as of October
23, with harvest still three weeks away.
Stephen Russell of Prodigal wines said that the “killer” frost in February may have been a blessing in
disguise, because it reduced the crop for just about all vineyards in the appellation, allowing the vines
to concentrate everything into less fruit. “Colors and flavors are intense and just about everyone is
predicting that it will be a very good year.”
Some reports indicate yields in Santa Barbara County in general are down 30%.
Dan Baumhefner had some interesting comments on
the trend in grape harvests in California. He
remembers when every year was a vintage year in
California. That ended in 1974, when the first of that
decade’s drought years was recorded. He notes that
every year since then has been weird for one reason
or another. After the drought years ended in the late seventies, the first El Nino floods arrived in the early eighties. “Since then, we seem to always
havestrange weather, with the effects all over the spectrum from severe flooding to seemingly endless
drought every year. Each year is totally different than the last. The effects change, but the cause
remains the same.” Don’s nominee for the cause of all this is global warming. Prior to 1974, every year
was very similar to every other year in California. Every New Years Day was sunny and warm in
Pasadena. The harvest in the Russian River Valley always began on September 1 for sparkling wine
grapes, September 15 for early ripening Chardonnay and Pinot Noir for table wine, and finished on
Halloween with the last of the late ripening Cabernet Sauvignon and Zinfandel. All of the winemakers
then took their kids out for trick or treat and life was good. Now we start harvesting in July and
Chardonnay is a late ripening variety, being picked in October!
Finger Lakes Has Its Own Challenges
The Finger Lakes region is a challenging area for successfully growing vitis vinifera. The winters are
cold, vine diseases are always a threat and ripening is often an issue. The Cornell Daily Sun (October
23, 2007) reports that the answer might lie in newer hybrid grape varieties. Professor Bruce Reisch, of
the Department of Horticultural Sciences at Cornell University, has been doing research on new disease-
resistant hybrid varieties that can withstand the frost of upstate New York and still develop the
types of flavors so desirable in table wine.
Testing of hybrid grapes can take as much as 20 years. Each year Reisch plants about 5,000 seedlings,
looking for that one new selection which displays promise. The new hybrids are more resistant to disease
and provide important environmental benefits because of the need for less pesticides and fungicides.
The Finger Lakes region has 80 wineries now, up from 45 in the late 1990s. Many of the wineries have
turned to the new hybrids which offer interesting flavor profiles in their own right. Corot Noir makes a
light red wine with cherry and raspberry flavors. Melody has notes of lemon and peach and is close to
Reisling in taste. Other hybrids being grown include Valvin Muscat, Cayuga White, Noiret, and Traminette.
Cayuga White, developed in 1972 as the first Cornell hybrid, now accounts for between $10 and
$15 million dollars of wine production each vintage.
The biggest hurdle that hybrid wines face is that
they are perceived as inferior to ones made with
vinifera grapes. There are also a number of proponents
in the region who are adamantly against
hybrid varieties. Hermann J. Weiner came to the
Finger Lakes region in the early 1970s to work at
Bully Hill Winery on Keuka Lake. He was fired for
developing an experimental nursery of vinifera
vines. He later became famous for producing the
first dry Riesling in the United States. This year,
Weiner sold his winery to Fred Merwarth who is
also a supporter of vinifera varieties. Weiner exclaimed,
“Fred’s a vinifera man and he’s allergic
Bonacorssi Wine Company
Michael Bonaccorsi was a talented sommelier who distinguished himself at Masa’s Restaurant in San
Francisco and later for almost ten years at the original Spago Restaurant in Los Angeles. His passion
for wine led him to become the twentieth Master Sommelier in the United States. He had a knack for
matching wine and food and making diners comfortable through his unpretentious approach to wine.
He met Jenne Lee, a native of Seoul, Korea, while she was working at Spago and the two married.
Fittingly, they were married in Burgundy. In 1999, they formed the Bonaccorsi Wine Company,
sourcing grapes from premium vineyards in Santa Barbara County and San Luis Obispo County. From
their first vintage, the wines were well received by the wine press and sommelier community .
Tragically, Michael passed away suddenly from a heart attack in 2004 at the age of 43. Undaunted,
Jenne Lee has kept the Bonacorssi label going, making the wines with the assistance of winemaker
Sashi Moorman (Stolpman). The winery is located in the Lompoc “Wine Ghetto.” In addition, as a
lasting memorial to Michael, Jenne Lee has started the Michael Bonaccorsi Scholarship Fund for
viticulture students at University of California Davis. An annual fundraiser is held in West Los Angeles
each year (www.bonaccorsifoundation.com).
I had the pleasure of sampling four recent releases from Bonacorssi Wine Company. In addition to the
two 2004 wines tasted, there were a Cargasacchi Vineyard and Melville Vineyard bottling. In 2005,
besides the Santa Rita Hills and Presidio Vineyard bottlings described here, there is a Sanford &
Benedict Vineyard spring release and a Cargasacchi Vineyard, Fiddlestix Vineyard and Melville
Vineyard Pinot Noir all of which will be available in November, 2007. The wines are aged 18 months in
50% new French oak.
2005 Bonaccorsi Wine Company Sta. Rita Hills Pinot Noir
15.1% alc., 400 cases, $55.
Composed of fruit from Cargasacchi, Melville and Fiddlestix
vineyards. Clones 115 and Pommard.
Lightest in color of the wines tasted. The nose is introverted even after two hours showing restrained notes of red fruit, hay and oak. There is a rich palate of primarily red cherry and red berry fruit with a hint of anise and a texture of milky softness.
2005 Bonaccorsi Wine Company Presidio Vineyard Santa Barbara County Pinot Noir
15.1% alc., 150 cases, $60.
A demure aromatic profile of organic matter and dark crushed berries. The alcohol
peaks out a tad on the nose as the wine warms in the glass but is not intrusive. Packed with sweet dark
cherry and black raspberry fruit with an oak sidecar. Very satiny and sensual texture. The whole package
is quite enjoyable and this is clearly my favorite.
Bonaccorsi Wine Company wines are sold on the website, www.bonawine.com, and through retail
channels. The 2005 spring releases are sold out at the winery. The 2005 vintage wines are strikingly
silky in texture and demonstrate a harmonious integration of oak. They will appeal to fans of biggerstyled,
virile and opulent Pinot Noir.
To Drink or Not to Drink?
A large review of the medical literature on the health benefits of alcohol was published recently in the
medical journal, Circulation (2007;116:1306-1317). The report was from the Heart Institute, Good
Samaritan Hospital, and the Division of Cardiovascular Medicine, Keck School of Medicine, University
of Southern California, Los Angeles and the Department of Cardiology, Marshfield Clinic, Marshfield,
Wisconsin. The article is titled, “To Drink or Nor to Drink? That is the Question.” The authors are
Robert A. Kloner, MD, PhD and Shereif H. Rezkalia, MD.
As the authors point out, the scientific debate over the health risks and benefits of alcohol dates back
several centuries starting in Europe and continuing to the present time. All of the studies to date are
observational and epidemiological. There has been no long-term prospective, randomized trial in
which one group abstains and a second group receives 1 drink of alcohol, perhaps as red wine, once a
day or once every other day, and followed long term. That said, there are many studies that have
shown a J-shaped or U-shaped curve to describe the relationship between alcohol use and total
mortality (see figure below). The optimal benefit of alcohol occurs at approximately a ½ a drink per
day. Less than 4 drinks per day in men and fewer than 2 drinks per day in women appear to bestow
benefit. Beyond these amounts, there is an increased mortality.
In the United States, a standard alcoholic drink is a 12 oz of beer, 5 oz of wine, or 1.5 oz of 80 proof
spirits or liquor. Some studies have shown an advantage of wine over other types of alcoholic
beverages, but other research indicates that the type of drink is not important.
The overwhelming majority of data indicates that moderate drinking benefits the cardiovascular
system. Light drinking has no current definition but is presumably less than moderate drinking.
Moderate drinking is defined as no more than 1 drink per day for women and no more than 2 drinks
per day for men. Heavy drinking is more than 1 drink per day for women and more than 2 drinks per
day for men. Binge drinking, which is clearly unhealthy, is more than 3 drinks for women and more
than 4 drinks for men on a single occasion over 2 hours.
At least a portion of the benefit of alcohol is due to decreased coronary artery disease deaths. Light to
moderate drinking has many beneficial effects on the cardiovascular system and the proposed
mechanisms include: increased high-density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL), decreased plasma
viscosity, increased fibrinolysis, decreased platelet aggregation, improved vascular endothelial lining
function, decreased vascular inflammation, and beneficial antioxidant effects. These benefits translate
to: decreased cardiovascular death, decreased nonfatal myocardial infarction, decreased
development of heart failure (and no exacerbation of heart failure) in patients with underlying heart
failure, decreased coronary heart disease, and decreased total mortality.
Heavy drinking is associated with many harmful effects: increased mortality, high blood pressure,
alcoholic cardiomyopathy, ventricular arrythmias, hemorrhagic stroke, cirrhosis, diabetes, cancer and
unnatural and sudden death.
There is one significant issue with regard to women and drinking that has not been resolved. Until
recently, some research had shown that there was a 10% increase in breast cancer in women who had
light to moderate intake of alcohol. However, middle-aged and older women with adequate folic acid
(found in leafy greens, citrus fruits, beans and peas) in their diet and were not on hormone
replacement therapy had the same incidence of breast cancer in light to moderate drinkers of wine as
abstainers. One caveat is that breast cancer is not the number one killer of women as many people
believe. Cardiovascular disease is the major cause of death in women and research has shown that
there is a 50% reduction in cardiovascular disease in women who are light to moderate wine drinkers.
A recent study by researchers at the Kaiser Permanente Division of Research in Oakland, California,
led by noted authority on the health benefits of alcohol, Dr. Arthur Klatsky, confirmed a higher risk of
breast cancer in women who were moderate drinkers . At the European Cancer Conference held in
late September in Barcelona, Spain, Klatsky reported that women who drank one or two drinks a day
increased their risk of breast cancer by 10%, compared to light drinkers (less than 1 drink a day). The
risk increased to 30% in women who drank more than 3 drinks per day, whether the drink of choice
was wine, beer or liquor. This 30% increased risk is comparable to the risk exposure of women who
smoke a pack of cigarettes a day or take estrogenic hormones. Epidemiological research studies like
Klatsky reported are often flawed by residual confounding (an unmeasurable factor). The group of
women in this study were mostly affluent and well-educated women who drank a lot of white wine. It is
known that it is polyphenols found in red wine that confer protection against cancer.
The issues involved in the health benefits of alcohol are all very
convoluted and complex. Until the defintive word comes out, do as I do,
drink 2 glasses of Pinot Noir every day with dinner. And have your wife
do as mine does, drink 1 glass of Pinot Noir every day with dinner. I
should also add that I frequently bath in Pinot Noir but you may not want
to try this at home.
Circulation is available at www.circ.ahajournals.org.
Red Car Wine Co: Life is a Journey
Mark Estrin and Carroll Kemp (Estrin is pictured on the left) of Red
Car Wine Company released their first wine in 2000. In their earliest
newsletter offering, they talked about their beginnings. “Smart people
tell you that whenever you start a business it’s a good idea to have
a theme that runs like a clear, cool stream through everything the
business does. We knew that before we got Red Car rolling and we
certainly tried to come up with a compelling one liner. But no matter
how hard we tried we couldn’t quite get it right. This was particularly
frustrating since one of us was a screenwriter for a number of years
and the other produced films. Then, we were driving down a gravel
road near Santa Ynez. We stopped and got out to look at a small vineyard
on the other side of a wire fence. The dirt was light tan, studded
with white rocks and stones. The air was pure and sweet. The sky was blue and powdered with high
clouds. We just stood there. It was so quiet you could hear birds chirping a mile away And then one
of us said, We tell stories. That’s what we’ve always done. That’s what we’re doing now, only with
wine. Winemaking is storytelling. The weather, soil and vine are woven together to tell the story of a
particular vintage and a particular place. We relate that story when we’re fortunate enough to meet
you in person or when we communicate by newsletter or phone or email. We try to make our labels
entertain and delight you. And finally, when you drink one of our wines, you are actually participating
in that story.”
The two partners had the right idea and their labels on their upper tier wines offered a prose written
by Estrin, each vintage offering a new chapter in an ongoing 1940s-era melodrama. The name Red Car
was chosen as it evoked memories of the now defunct Los Angeles Red Car Trolley line. For Pinot Noir
(they also produced Syrah from the start), they chose the name, Amour Fou, which is a French expression
for a mad, obsessive love. The labels offered a tragic love affair that takes place in 1940s Los
Angeles. The first release in 2002 featured a married man named Jack recollecting how his mad
passion for another woman has lead him to a very dark place. The subsequent vintages carried on the
Unfortunately, Mark Estrin died in May, 2005 at the age of 57 from a brain tumor. He had a successful
career in screenwriting beginning in 1979, but left that field in 1994 to pursue his passion for wine.
Estrin worked at both Wally’s Liquor in Westwood and the Wine House in West Los Angeles. The unique Red Car approach to wine was fostered by his years selling wine to the public. He was beloved
for his quiet sense of humor and a sophisticated taste for fine food, wine and cigars.. And although the
distinctive Red Car labels and marketing drew much attention because of his efforts, the quality of the
wines quickly caught the public’s admiration. Robert Parker wrote, “Red Car has the “Midas Touch”
when it comes to producing wines of character and richness.”
After Estrin’s passing, Carroll Kemp continued to lead a team to improve the quality and character of
the Red Car wines in his honor. The initial winemaker was Tim Spear who left to concentrate on his
Clos Mimi label. In 2004, Sashi Moorman (Stolpman) and Chris King (Lewis Cellars) came on board the
Red Car as consulting and assistant winemaker respectively.
The Amour Fou Pinot Noirs are blends. The initial partners, Carroll and Mark, were not “terroir-istes”
at the start. They believed in making the best wines they could from more than one vineyard source.
In 2004, Red Car Wine Company raised enough investment capital to buy 128 acres along the Sonoma
Coast and vineyards developed here may change Red Car’s commitment to “single vineyard-istes.”
Carroll says “we now prefer Pinot sites that are on the cool climatic edge. This allows us to obtain
boldly ripe fruit that is still balanced with the zing of acidity. In California, this happens in Western
Sonoma County or ‘West County’ in local-speak. Our new sites in the ‘true’ Sonoma Coast will give us
another step forward when our ‘05s are released.” Their first vineyard-designate Pinot Noir, The Aphorist,
was released with the 2005 vintage (see below).
The style of winemaking has evolved over the six vintages to date. Mark and Carroll produced their
first two barrels of Syrah essentially in Carroll’s Beverly Hill’s garage. The initial vintage of Pinot Noir
in 2002 was made like their Syrah and was quite popular with the press and Parker who preferred big,
extracted Pinot Noirs. The focus now has reversed and the Syrahs are made more like their Pinot
Noirs. The latest Amour Fou still has vivid fruit but is crafted with more subtlety and complexity in
The Red Car Amour Fou Pinot Noirs released to date include the following. 2002: 70% Keefer Ranch
Vineyard (Green Valley) and 30% Cloud’s Rest Vineyard (Sonoma Coast), 237 cases, $40. 2003: 70%
Keefer Ranch Vineyard, 30% Sleeping Beauty Vineyard (George Martinelli owned,
Russian River Valley), 275 cases, $45. 2004: 53% D. Giovanetti Vineyard (inaugural
vintage, a Red Car Monopole, Green Valley), 47% Sleeping Beauty Vineyard, 400
cases, $50. 2005: 55% Bartolomei Vineyard (Sonoma Coast), 36% Sleeping Beauty
Vineyard, 9% La Boheme Vineyard, aged in 73% new French oak, 273 cases, $55. A
second bottling in 2005 was labeled The Aphorist. This was sourced 100% from
Bartolomei Vineyard and aged in 100% new French oak, 48 cases. Red Car also produces
a value-priced Pinot Noir and Rosé labeled Boxcar.
2005 Red Car Wine Company Amour Fou Pinot Noir
14.8% alc., 273 cases, $55.
This wine is royal in appearance with a deep violet robe. Intriguing aromatics of dark Pinot fruits, toast and cigar box. Heady black cherry and forest floor flavors are embraced by well-concealed tannins. Sleek and seductive in the mouth, this beauty ends with a long, chewy aftertaste that has a haunting cherry aroma. Very tasty.
Red Car Wine Company wines are sold primarily through a mailing list at
. There is limited restaurant and retail (mainly Los Angeles)
distribution. The phone is 310-839-7300. The wines are produced at Central
Coast Wine Services in Santa Maria, CA. Offices are in Culver City, CA. The website
is very impressive and the newsletter, The Almanac, is the best in the business.
Making Sense of Alcohol
Alcohol content in wine, mainly ethyl alcohol, is expressed in percent by volume of the total liquid. Brix
(symbol Bx) is the measurement of the ratio of dissolved sucrose sugar to water in a liquid such as grape juice
and is expressed in percent or degrees. For example, 25° Bx solution is 25% with 25 grams of sucrose sugar
and 75 grams of water in 100 grams of solution. Knowing the Brix of the grapes prior to fermentation, the potential alcohol of the finished wine can be determined if all of the sugar is fermented. A pre-fermentation Brix or sugar content of 22.5° of grape juice will produce a potential alcohol of 13.0%, 24.8° Brix will produce14.3 %,
and 25,8° Brix will produce 15.1%.
The Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (TTB) requires that the alcohol be stated on the front or back
label of a bottle of wine (the exception is wines between 7% and 14% alcohol which may be labeled “table
wine” or “light wine”). The tax rates for wine are determined first by whether the wine is over 14% (considered
dessert wine) or under 14% (a table wine) and then by the tolerance (called “label leeway”) levels. Mislabeling
of alcohol content is a serious federal offense.
The tolerance range for under 14% wines is 1.5% (for example, a 12.5% wine may be labeled anywhere from
11% to 14%). The tolerance range for over 14% wines is 1% (a wine labeled 15% may have from 14.01 to 16%
alcohol). It is not permissible for a tolerance level to cross tax classes - for example, a wine at or below 14%
cannot be labeled as above 14%, and a wine above 14% cannot be labeled as less than 14.01%. This tolerance
level allows many wineries to downplay their alcohol levels so be forewarned!
Wonder why so many French and other European wines are labeled 12.5%? It is because wines with more
alcohol than 14% are taxed 50% higher.
Acker Merrill & Condit Auction
The Acker Merrill & Condit Golden Cellar Auction was
held this past weekend in New York. Of the top 20
grossing lots, 15 were Burgundies. A total of more than
15.5 million dollars worth of wine was auctioned, the
second highest grossing wine auction ever.
The top lot was a Methuselah of 1999 Domaine de la
Romanee Conti Romanee Conti fetching $127,050. A
Methuselah holds 6 liters or 8 bottles of wine.
12 bottles of 1962 A. Rousseau Chambertin brought
$108,900, 12 bottles of 1978 H. Jayer Echezeau sold for
$72,600, 12 bottles of 1969 A. Rousseau Chambertin
Clos de Beze went for $66,550 and 6 magnums of 1999
Domaine de la Romanee Conti La Tache brought
One could make a good argument for robbing a stock
portfolio and investing heavily in 2005 Burgundies from
top producers like Romanee Conti, Comte de Vogue, A.
Rousseau and so forth. The thirst for fine vintages of
Burgundy seems to spiral upward unabated and it is
easy to imagine healthy returns on such an investment
in the future. Sad to say, but great Burgundy today is
more likely to be traded like a stock than drank as a